How To Sell Your Coin Collection

How To Sell Your Coin Collection

Steven Cochran
Published: April 06, 2022
Table Of Contents:

You may be a person who has inherited a “box of old coins,” or you may be a numismatist looking to change direction with your collection. In any case, you need advice on how to sell your coin collection for the best price.

Follow the three simple steps below to get the most when selling your coin collection.

coin collection

Selling a coin collection can be very rewarding if done properly.

#1: Find Out What Coins You Have

If you’re a coin collector, you already know what you have. Feel free to jump to “Step #2: Find the current market price for each coin.”

If you’re a non-coin person, determining which coins you have can be done with a few simple resources. You could also get the collection appraised at a local coin shop, especially if you’re looking to sell via that method.

Here are some great resources for beginners:

  • The Red Book: The Whitman Guide to US Coins, aka “the Red Book,” is considered an indispensable resource for coin collectors. It gives mintages for each coin produced by the United States, and comparative prices. The actual prices are not indicative of the current price for any coin, but the price spread between common dates and rare dates of the same coin type illustrates their relative scarcity.

  • PCGS Coinfacts and Photograde: The Professional Coin Grading Service was the first company to offer certification and condition grading for rare coins. Their online resources include Coinfacts, where you can learn the rarity of your coins; and Photograde Online, which allows you to see what each coin type looks like in different states of wear.

  • Look Up Key Dates and Varieties of Your Coins: Key dates are the hard-to-find coins that are required to complete a coin set. Key date coins are usually the most expensive of their coin series, possibly excluding rare varieties. For an example of key dates in a coin series, we recommend Key Date Morgan Dollars: Collecting Tips and Prices.

Varieties are coins where something happened during the minting process to make them different from ordinary coins. Types of varieties include die doubling and repunched mint marks.

Some varieties are very hard to detect unless you know what to look for. Even experienced collectors should check their coins to see if one is a valuable variety that slipped through the cracks and into their collection.

Many types of variety coins are far more valuable than the “normal” version. This makes it worth your while to double check any coin that seems like it’s different from the normal strike. Searching for varieties online will pull up the better known examples, such as the 1955 Doubled Die Obverse Lincoln Cent.

#2: Find the Market Price for Each Coin

Finding a current market price for your rare coin collection is an imprecise science, at best. Unlike fungible assets like stocks or smartphones, every coin is different—even from the same mint and year. The older the coin, the greater the variability between them.

This means that even the most up-to-date information is nothing but a rough guide to a coin’s value. There are some places where that information is more credible than others.

  • CDN Greysheet Prices: The CDN Greysheet is a market price guide for coin dealers. If you have a bunch of coins that your research shows are valuable, it may be worth spending $8 for a single month’s access to this online coin price guide. Most of these prices are updated weekly, with some updated more often. Follow the link to reference the Greysheet Coin and Currency Pricing for Dealers and Collectors.

  • Online Auction Records: The big coin auction houses such as Heritage, Stack’s Bowers, and Great Collections post realized prices from their coin auctions. You can search these records to see what coins like yours have sold for. (Heritage’s site is the easiest to search.)

Remember that prices posted will include the buyer’s premium, which can be as much as 20% of the hammer price.

Confine your searches to the last one or two years. Older auction results can reflect prices realized during the last rare coin bubble. This is why current auction records for many coins were set ten or more years ago.

How to Determine a Coin's Melt Value

If you have worn “common date” dimes, quarters, half dollars or silver dollars, you might get more money selling them for their silver content instead of at a low numismatic value. Any US dime, quarter, or half dollar made in 1964 or earlier has silver making up 90% of its weight. The common name for these coins is “junk silver.”

90_percent_silver_coin

An assortment of 90 percent silver coins.

Morgan and Peace silver dollars will sell for slightly more than their silver content, unless their features have been almost completely worn away. Of course, common-date gold coins have a far better chance of having a melt value exceeding their numismatic value.

Before selling an old silver or gold coin, determine its “melt value”—the value of the silver or gold the coin contains, using current gold or silver prices. That way, you can tell if a buyer is trying to take advantage of you.

Use our Gold and Silver Coin Melt Value Calculator to find the melt value of your coins. You can also consult the chart below to do the calculation manually.

Remember that you won’t be offered 100% of melt value if you are selling “junk silver,” but if someone offers you less than melt value on a numismatic coin, you may want to walk instead of argue. You should know what your coins are worth after doing your research.

Actual Silver Weight (ASW) US Junk Silver Coins (Chart)

Denomination
ASW
Melt Value
Pre-1965 Dime0.0723 troy ozSpot silver price x 0.0723
Pre-1965 Quarter0.1818 troy ozSpot silver price x 0.1818
Pre-1965 Half Dollar0.36169 troy ozSpot silver price x 0.36169
40% Kennedy Half Dollars0.1479 troy ozSpot silver price x 0.1479
Large Silver Dollars (Morgan or Peace)0.7734 troy ozSpot silver price x 0.7734
40% Eisenhower "S" Silver Dollars (1971–1976)0.3161 troy ozSpot silver price x 0.3161
35% "War Nickels" (1942–1945)0.0563 troy ozSpot silver price x 0.0563

REMEMBER: A scarce date or variety of a coin can be worth far more than its melt value, even in greatly worn condition.

Coin Grading: Certified (Slabbed) Coins

Coins that have been certified and graded by a professional coin grading service are sonically sealed in a protective clear plastic “slab.” Slabbed coins fetch higher prices and are easier to sell than uncertified “raw” coins. Buyers have the peace of mind that a slabbed coin is genuine, and is graded properly.

The question of when to send a coin to a third-party grading service can depend on your objective. Some collectors prefer all their coins in a set be slabbed, usually at the same grade. Return on Investment (ROI) for these collectors is a lesser concern than for collectors who want to enhance the value of their coins on the resell market.

Deciding whether or not to send a coin to a TPG for certification can be tricky. Do you send a $100 coin in to be graded when it can cost nearly $30 to do so?

Adding the grading fee to the price you paid for the coin might leave little room for profit. The situation changes with higher value coins. In those cases, the extra money you would get for selling the coin slabbed could far outpace the cost of getting it graded.

#3: Find the Right Buyer for Your Coin Collection

Now that you know what coins you have and a rough idea of what they’re worth, it’s time to find a buyer.

Note that these suggestions are for numismatic/collector coins. If you have bullion coins like American Silver Eagles or Canadian Gold Maple Leafs, you can probably walk into a pawn shop and walk out with money (though not as much as selling to an online bullion company).

silver eagle coin collection

Some dates of the American Silver Eagle coins are highly collectible, such as the 1995-W.

Different Types of Coin Buyers

Different coins will sell better to different buyers. Your set of Buffalo Nickels or Walking Liberty Half Dollars are going to sell better to a local coin shop or a fellow collector. Whereas a type set of pre-Civil War gold coins from the Dahlonega or Charlotte mints will probably fetch a better price from a coin dealer specializing in high-value coins, or an auction house.

The first place you should look to sell your coin collection is the place where you bought the coins. You already know that they buy and sell the type of coins you are selling. Don’t expect to get back what you paid for them, though. The seller is running a business, not a coin library!

Other Coin Collectors

If you’re a member of a coin club, this is another market for coins you’re selling. You probably know other people who collect the same coins you do.

Don’t join a coin club just to try and sell your coins. That’s the best way to ruin the local market for you, since word will get out to coin store owners.

Coin Shops

Local coin shops should be your go-to destination for low- and medium-value coins. Everything from nice Wheat cents to semi-key date Morgan dollars should find a home at one of your local coin shops. Some shops will even buy old small gold coins.

Online Marketplaces

Another avenue is online marketplaces such as eBay or Facebook Marketplace. This requires more effort than selling to a coin shop or fellow collector, and can open up a risk of losing your coins or money if a buyer files a dispute. EBay in particular will side with the buyer in 99% of all disputes, leaving you with no recourse.

Coin Shows

Coin shows are a good place to see what coins like yours are selling for. It’s also a great place to make acquaintances with coin dealers. Coin shows are busy places, so don’t feel put out if a dealer can’t devote a lot of time examining your coin collection. Even if they are too busy during the show, you can follow up with them later.

Online Coin Companies

Online coin companies have the capital to purchase entire coin collections, even high-end ones. You won’t find common date minor coins here, except those being sold as junk silver. Your local coin shop or fellow collectors are more appropriate venues for those types of coins.

One thing to be aware of: you will have to insure and ship your coins to the dealer. You won’t be paid until they receive the coins.

Auction Houses

Auction houses fall into two broad categories: small, local ones and large ones that aim for an international audience. Small auction houses tend to be more specialized. Daniel Sedwick, for example, specializes in shipwreck coins and Spanish colonial cobs.

On the other hand, auction houses like Heritage or Stack’s Bowers conduct auctions for all kinds of collectibles, not just coins. They are focused on online auctions that cater to an international audience.

The downside to international exposure for your coins that an auction provides is that you don’t know how much you will get for your coins until the auction is over. High seller’s fees are another drawback. It can also take weeks after the auction closes to be paid.

Selling Your Coins: The Payoff

If you’ve done your due diligence on the value of your coins and taken the time to market them to the correct buyer, you can feel confident that you received a fair value for your coin collection. Whether you were “cashing out” or simply selling off coins to take your collection in a different direction, you can congratulate yourself on a job well done!


Read more about coin collecting and selling coins from the numismatic experts at Gainesville Coins:

How to Sell Coins: The 5 Best Tips

How to Sell Your Old Coins

Coin Collecting for Kids: A Beginner's Guide

How to Buy Gold Coins: Essential Advice to Get Started

Most Asked Questions About US Mint Coins: Buyer's Guide

1921 Peace Silver Dollar: Values & Mintages

Posted In: blog
Login to post comment Login
Steven Cochran

Steven Cochran

Precious Metals Market Analyst | BS University of South Florida (2002)

A published writer, Steven's coverage of precious metals goes beyond the daily news to explain how ancillary factors affect the market.

Steven specializes in market analysis with an emphasis on stocks, corporate bonds, and government debt.

Latest Offers, Straight To Your Inbox

Don't be the last to know about the latest deals and new product arrivals. Join us today for FREE!