How To Sell Coins: 5 Essential Tips

How To Sell Coins: 5 Essential Tips

Joshua McMorrow-Hernandez
Published: November 11, 2021
Jump To Section:

Want to know how to sell coins? You may have found yourself considering a wide variety of options for potential buyers, including selling coins in-person and online. You want to understand the selling process and how to get the most money for your coins.

But there seem to be almost too many answers out there, and none may seem like they quite fit your particular situation. What do you do? Hopefully, this article helps. We’ll give you the rundown on the best ways and places to sell coins. You’ll also find five of our top tips for selling coins, and finding out what they’re worth, among other important things. 

favorite coins

Examples of well-known bullion coins: (from left to right) American Gold Eagle, Australian Gold Kangaroo, and Canadian Silver Maple Leaf.

5 Top Tips for Selling Coins

Whether you decide to sell your coins in-person or online, there are several helpful hints to make your transaction go more smoothly while also getting the most money for your coins. These include the following five tips for selling coins: 

1. Don’t clean your coins – Many people seem to think they should clean their coins to make them “look pretty” before selling them. This is done with the motive of trying to make more money on the sale. Yet this actually makes the coins worth less. It’s incalculable how much numismatic value goes down the drain each year with people cleaning their coins before selling them. Don’t clean your coins! Not only does this cut their value by as much as half (or possibly even more), but it will be an immediate deal-breaker for many dealers who would’ve otherwise wanted to buy your coins if only they were left in their original condition. 

2. Know what you have – Some people who sell their coins do so because they inherited them and otherwise have no interest in the coins themselves. This lack of knowledge can be a significant disadvantage to the seller. You might know when you are getting a good offer (or not) by simply understanding what it is you’re selling. Do you have slabbed coins (i.e. graded coins)? Do you have a large collection of mint sets or proof sets? There are many great resources to help you gain more knowledge about your coins, including the informative coin articles on this website and publications such as A Guide Book of United States Coins, a popular annual release by Whitman Publishing. 

3. Find out the approximate value of your coins – You’ll want to know approximately how much your coins are worth before selling them. But before you do this, remember that most coin price guides out there are giving you a retail value. The retail value is how much the coins are worth if you’re buying them from a dealer. The amount you’ll earn for selling those same coins could be anywhere from 20% to 50% less than the prices listed in those guides, depending on the given coin and its condition. Why? This is because dealers buy at wholesale prices, which allows them to pay for business operating costs such as overhead and wages. Don’t expect to receive the prices listed in any retail coin price guides. Also keep in mind that coins or paper money in poor condition may only be worth their face value.

4. Get a fix on current bullion prices – If you’re selling gold or silver coins, you’re most likely going to receive an offer pegged at or around the spot metal value of your material. The spot price is an amount of money equivalent to the value of the bullion metal in your coins. In other words, the melt value. For example, if your coin contains a one-half ounce of gold in metal content, its spot value is 50% of the value for an ounce of gold, the unit of measure most often cited for gold (and silver) prices. This is where it behooves you to find out the current metals prices. You’ll know roughly what to expect for an offer when you go to sell coins with precious metals in them. 

5. Minimize risks to you and your coins when selling them – There are a few precautions you should take to keep you and your coins safe before and after selling them. Make sure you aren’t being followed around by someone else while coins are in your possession. Many dealers and collectors are robbed this way after being tailed by a thief on the road. For similar safety reasons, keep your transactions discreet. There’s no need to flaunt what you’ve got and are soon selling. And if shipping your coins in the mail for an online transaction, keep words like “coin,” “bullion,” “gold,” “silver,” etc., off the outer packaging; envelopes and boxes decorated with words like these simply invite thieves to open and steal its contents. 

Coin Collecting Gaffer

You may have to closely your inspect your coins to identify them, such as finding the mint mark.

Selling Coins In-Person vs. Online

In today’s world of e-commerce and digital sales, you no longer have to go to a brick-and-mortar store to buy what you want. The same goes for selling, too. Yes, you definitely can still buy and sell coins at a traditional storefront coin dealer, and there are some benefits to doing this that we’ll address in a moment. But if you cannot go to a coin dealer to sell your coins or don’t want to, there are viable options for selling coins online.

Selling coins in-person affords a few definitive benefits. These include getting to talk with a coin dealer face-to-face about what you want to sell, answering each other’s questions about your material in real-time. You can also walk away with a check at the moment of sale—no waiting for one to arrive in the mail. So, what about selling coins online?

Of course, this process becomes a little more drawn out but has benefits all its own. You can list coins on an auction website or sell them to a coin dealer. Some dealers advertise exactly what they are buying on their websites and even offer virtual quote cards suggesting what they’ll pay for certain coins. Other coin dealers request you send them the coins you wish to sell for an offer and/or payment upon receipt.

Online and virtual coin sales frequently require more time to get an offer, and there are more trips to the post office to get your coins where they need to be sold. However, selling coins online and sending them through the mail is a convenient alternative for those in small towns or far-flung locales where there aren’t major coin dealers near them to sell to. This is also an excellent option for selling coins to a dealer who needs the material you want to sell, thus increasing your odds of getting a more substantial offer.

coin collection

A collection of coins and common supplies used by coin collectors.

Popular U.S. Coins to Look For

As we pointed out in Tip #2, one common problem is that someone who inherits a coin collection may have no idea what kind of coins they have. Any competent coin dealer will be able to identify the coins for you. But if you'd like to arm yourself with knowledge ahead of time, here's a list of some of the most popular United States coins to collect. The links provided will direct you to images of these coin designs so you can easily recognize them.

Selling Coins for Top Dollar at Gainesville Coins

With the market the way it’s been lately, there’s never been a better time to sell coins. Whether you decide to liquidate them online or in person, the best place you’ll have is to sell them to Gainesville Coins. Unlike auction websites, there is no seller's fee.

We’ve been in business since 2006 and are one of the most respected and trusted coin dealers around. We have a brick-and-mortar storefront in Lutz, Florida, just a few miles north of Tampa, and offices worldwide. You can easily find us on social media. We also buy coins online, making it the easiest way for you to sell us your coins no matter where you are.

If you're ready to sell your coins to the right place, follow the link!

It's always a good sign when a coin dealer is a member of prestigious industry organizations. Examples include the American Numismatic Association (ANA), the Professional Numismatists Guild (PNG), and third-party grading services such as Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) and Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC). The dealer should also have a profile with the Better Business Bureau (BBB), where an A+ rating is given for promptly responding to customer concerns.

For more information about selling your coins to Gainesville Coins, please email us or give us a call at (813) 482-9300. One of our expert coin professionals will be glad to further educate you on how to sell your coins to us and a fair price of how much they might be worth.  


Joshua McMorrow-Hernandez is a journalist, editor, and blogger who has won multiple awards from the Numismatic Literary Guild. He has also authored numerous books, including works profiling the history of the United States Mint and United States coinage.

More information about buying and selling coins from the numismatic experts at Gainesville Coins:

How To Sell Your Silver Coins

Coin Collecting for Kids: A Beginner's Guide

Get Started Collecting Coins: A How To Guide for the Beginner

Top 13 Error Coins Worth Money - Price Guide

U.S. Mint Coins For Sale: Buyer's Guide

Junk Silver FAQs: Frequently Asked Questions About 90% Silver Coins

Posted In: blog

Latest Offers, Straight To Your Inbox

Don't be the last to know about the latest deals and new product arrivals. Join us today for FREE!